Senator Abel Maldonado
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Monday, April 05, 2010 5:09 PM
To: 'Assemblymember.John.Perez@assembly.ca.gov'
Cc: 'Senator.Maldonado@senate.ca.gov'; 'assemblymember.blakeslee@assembly.ca.gov'
Subject: RE: Our California Constitution
Dear Assembly Member Perez, Senator Maldonado and Assembly Member Sam Blakeslee
I have added this video to YOUTUBE addressed to the State Senators and Assembly Members.
Please review Caltrans Actions:
California State Assemblymebers--John Perez, California State Senators Abel Maldonado
California State Assemblymebers--John Perez, California State Senators Abel Maldonado
November 26, 2008 after Judge Martin J. Tangeman ruled against this being Causation for the flooding of our State Highway 1 ... Inverse Condemnation ...
16 minutes ago 0 views InverseCondemnation1
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Monday, April 05, 2010 12:55 PM
To: '
Cc: '
Subject: RE: Our
April 5, 2010
Dear State Assembly Members, John Perez, California State Senators and all News Media
Re: San Luis Obispo Superior Court Judge Martin J. Tangeman ignoring, Video--Causation Evidence/Testimony, California Case law and allowing the
Our State Highway 1 has flooded and been closed 13 time this year in 2010--See Caltrans Response to the Regional Water Quality Control Board above after Judge Martin J. Tangeman’s Inverse Condemnation decision!
Caltrans, County of San Luis Obispo and the Oceano Community Service District actions are now on YOUTUBE and at www.oceanonursery.com State Senators and Assembly Members---Why is Caltrans allowed to shovel and grade their contaminated debris into the Caltrans, County and Oceano Community’s drainage system, that leads to our Pacific Ocean; even after Judge Tangeman made his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision?
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
On May 6, 2010 in the San Luis Obispo Supervisors chambers will be herd our oral arguments in the Inverse Condemnation Case Bookout V. State of California. County Of San Luis Obispo withholding of whiteness’s and evidence from Discovery and Judge Tangeman ignoring California Case Law ---Arreola v. Monterey County (2002) __Cal.App.4th__ [2002 Cal. App. LEXIS 4319].
Every State Assembly Member and State Senator should be aware of what the San Luis Obispo Superior Court Judge Martin J. Tangeman has Stated in his August 5, 2008 Superior Court decision regarding Inverse Condemnation: Judge Tangeman misheard Caltrans Testimony on Page 936 As stated by Caltrans—“Now, the we saw earlier a photograph of a Caltrans loader, as you described it , actually in the channel. Do you have I mean, can you tell us why that was done? To your understanding, why that would have been done? Answer. I would imagine that the loader was working in the area. The employee who was running the loader was probably a conscientious employee and wanted to try to help. Question. Do you have a problem with your employees doing Good Neighbor sort of deeds like that? Answer. NO, we do we try to do that when we can.”
Please view this YOUTUBE Video of Causation of this drainage system flooding our
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
San Luis Obispo Superior Court Judge Martin J. Tangeman Stated this in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation Decision rather then what Caltrans had testified to above! "Mr. Fry testified that any work undertaken by Cal Trans employees in the channel to help clear the channel were most likely undertaken solely as a "good neighbor" practice by a "conscientious employee”
Assembly Member John Perez, Assembly Members State Senators. Are
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
Caltrans Causation part of flooding our
Added to
Quicklist 1:04
Caltrans January 4, 2007 Soveling Debris into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage System
Caltrans January 4, 2007 Soveling Debris into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage System
into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage Channel! Judge Tangeman misheard Caltrans Testimony on Page 936 As stated--Now, the we saw ...
1 month ago 48 views
These are the Documents letters of whiteness, that where withheld from Discovery by The County Of San Luis Obispo and finally given to us in full on December 2, 2008 five months after our first trial with many depositions and whiteness testimony now being worthless This is how Union Pacific Railroad admitted part of exhibit # 579 and how Judge Tangeman allowed evidence to be withheld from discovery as seen in their statements at trial! “And for the purpose of the exhibits we don’t need the photographs.” Judge Tangeman-- The Court States: “All Right”
Bill Tatum 1539 Fountain Ave. ---2001 flooding of
Larry A Baughman--Owner of
Chuck Bachman--1519 and
Marquis Miller 548 Honolulu "Heavy Rains overflow lagoon"
Less Brown--
Jesser Esser--608 Air park Dr. "Storm Water Drainage Ditch next to
John W. Carter 1778 Aloha Place
Mary Fernald 590 Honolulu St. Problems in last five years
David and Penny Villalba 567-571
Raoul Cristin
Jan Dilo, Department of
R. George Rosenberg, Deputy Director of General Services County Of San Luis Obispo
Cynthia M. Joselson/Dennis A.Huebner---Photos
Franklin C. Owen --Flooding in the
In County of San Luis Obispo Files with drainage Studies and Color photos
September 7, 1990
October 1, 1990
October 17, 1990 Letter from John L. Wallace to OCSD Drainage in Oceano,
January 15, 1991
March 15, 1991
May 3, 1991 OCSD letter to SLO County Analysis of OCSD Storm Drainage Problem regarding future County Building Permits
September 23, 1991 letter to Ruth Bracket Sidewalks
September 25, 1991 letter from Ruth Brackett not talking about Paso Robles and 13th streets
November 18, 1991Oceano Halcyon Advisory Committee minutes Drainage in Oceano not Paso Robles and 13th streets ally ways sidewalks
February 10, 1992 Draft letter Sidewalks
February 12, 1992 OCSD Meeting minutes Regarding Cienaga flooding County Responsibility Drainage Director Baughman.
March 11, 1992 OCSD letter regarding Flooding of Oceano Slough below State highway 1
February 10, 1993 OCSD Minutes 11 C. Video of flooding problem on highway 1
June 8, 1993 OCSD memorandum Meeting on Arroyo Grande outfall
February 23, 1994 OCSD meeting minutes Concerns West of State highway 1
February 25, 1994 San Luis Obispo County Sanitation District letter to Tony Boyd County Engineering Dept.
July 26, 1995 OCSD Meeting minutes Cienaga flooding problem Concern with railroad subdividing their property. A problem at Paso
January 10, 1997 OCSD Letter to planning Commission County of San Luis Obispo
October 8, 1997 OCSD meeting Minutes Drainage Problems Bill Bookout Specifically on Airpark and
May 13, 1998 OCSD meeting Minutes "Front and Cienaga Drainage problem
October 14, 1999 San Luis Obispo County letter and documents of concern to Union Pacific Railroad regarding Cienaga Drainage not Paso Robles St.
January 25, 1999 letter from OCSD to Khatchik h. Achadjian-issues-Flooding and Drainage channel behind
January 29, 1999
February 5, 1999 OCSD letter to County regarding highway 1 Drainage issues not Paso Robles street.
November 10, 1999 Louis e. Wheeler letter to K.H. Achadjian
Whiteness Direct knowledge of State Highway 1 Drainage
Jay Jamison showing no flooding in 2002 with his knowledge of Highway 1.
Mark Hutctenreuther, knowledge of highway 1
Loni Silkwood, 1611 Paso Robles St Knowledge of highway 1--.
Jak Harris, knowledge of highway 1
Stanly Manel, knowledge of highway 1
Wilford P. Deschenes, knowledge of highway 1
R. Bliver, knowledge of highway 1
Jerry Bunin, 2280 Paso Robles St. Knowledge of highway 1--
Luis Wheeler, knowledge of highway 1 with photos taken of highway 1 and withheld from discovery including drainage in front of Oceano Market and Oceano Nursery.
Larry A Baughman--Owner of
"We Own a home at
"Water At The Corner Of 13th/Paso Robles/And Highway 1 Runs (Drains) Under The Railroad Tracks Across
Daniel Dena Neill--
Josue Astrero,Larry A Baughman--Knowledge of
Pat Clegg, Knowledge of
Sharon Collester, Knowledge of
Alan & Liane Barta, Knowledge of
Wando Cebulla, Knowledge of
Fred Cheda, 2231 Paso
Katherine B. Escobar 1627 Front Street, Knowledge of
Ben Harvey knowledge of Cal Trans changes to State Highway 1
Marylice Mankins
Eric Johnson Ally way knowledge
Herb West Knowledge of
Mark and Kristine Munro County Blaime wasting money on Study
Yvonne Putman 2591 Paso Robles--
Robert W. Raymond, Knowledge of State Highway 1--poor county planning--County Eng. Photos
Charles E Royal 1561 16th between Warner and Wilmar Errosion problems
Chris & Linda Schroder 'The End of 13th st. at Cienaga
James &Throck Scudder --"Warner & 15th-water travels down 15th and Warner"
Dean Sorensean 561 Security Court 'Several inches to 1 foot depending on amount and length of rain
Ailo Stananage 547
Dan Striciculerda
Fred Van Slyke flooding at cienaga 7 front every time it rains
These
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 4:49 PM
To: '
Cc:
Subject: RE:
Dear State Assembly Members and all News Media
In
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 221.wmv
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 221.wmv
California Supreme Court--Inverse Condemnation
California Supreme Court--Inverse Condemnation
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 4:17 PM
To: '
Cc: '
Subject: RE:
In
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 3:04 PM
To: '
Cc: '
Subject: RE:
Dear Senator Kehoe and all
Aanestad, Sam Alquist, Elaine Ashburn, Roy Calderon, Ron Cedillo, Gilbert Cogdill, Dave Corbett, Ellen Correa, Lou Cox, Dave Denham, Jeff DeSaulnier, Mark Ducheny, Denise Moreno Dutton, Robert D. Florez, Dean Hancock, Loni Harman, Tom Hollingsworth, Dennis Huff, Bob Kehoe, Christine Leno, Mark Liu, Carol Lowenthal, Alan S. Maldonado, Abel Oropeza, Jenny Padilla, Alex Pavley, Fran Price, Curren Romero, Gloria Runner, George Simitian, Joe Steinberg, Darrell Strickland, Tony Walters, Mimi Wiggins, Patricia Wolk, Lois Wright, Roderick Wyland, Mark Yee, Leland and all California News Media
Attached below are YouTube videos of Caltrans Caught shoveling contaminated storm water and debris into the Oceano Communities storm water drainage channel that now floods one of our State Highways, every time it rains.
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
San Luis Obispo Superior Court Judge Martin J. Tangeman has ruled this is just being a good neighbor, which has allowed Caltrans District 5 to continue their actions as seen in this first YouTube Video November 26, 2008.
Senator Kehoe, I ask that each California Senator is made aware of San Luis Obispo-Superior Court, Judge Martin J. Tangemans--August 5, 2008 Judgment Decision while this goes through the Appellate Court process and is made National News.
Please review Judge Tangemans Statements next to these You Tube Videos under Caltrans. My Web-Site www.oceanonursery.com has all of the Caltrans documents on it showing why they are now using State Highway 1 for storm water retention and endangering our publics health and safety in order to not flood the Baughman property!
Sincerely
Bill Bookout
1-805-773-2089
From: Bill Bookout [mailto:Pismobeachdiveshop@charter.net]
Sent: Friday, March 12, 2010 11:18 AM
To: '
Cc: '
Subject:
Dear Senator Abel Maldonado and State Assemblyman Sam Blakeslee
I hope that both of you have had a chance to watch these videos on YouTube of the State of California---Caltrans shoveling and grading contaminated storm water and debris into the Oceano Community’s storm water drainage channel. San Luis Obispo Superior Court Judge Martin J. Tangeman has ruled this is just being a good neighbor,
Could each of you explain your position on Caltrans actions to our local news media? It is my intention to bring this to our National News Media in the next couple of weeks, with the New Times Article that has come out this week.
Sincerely
Bill Bookout
Caltrans January 4, 2007 Soveling Debris into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage System
Caltrans January 4, 2007 Soveling Debris into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage System
which are a cause of the flooding of Appellants property. Judge Tangeman held that date of stabilization approach does not apply since the ...
2 weeks ago 25 views
Caltrans January 4, 2007 Soveling Debris into the Oceano Communities Storm Water Drainage System
1:04 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
which are a cause of the flooding of Appellants property. Judge Tangeman held that date of stabilization approach does not apply since the ...
25 views
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
1 week ago 21 views
Cal Trans January 2007 Regional Water Quality Control Board NPDES Permited
0:40 February 28, 2010
Comedy
surfshop1963
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
21 views
Cal Trans Drainage December 19, 2007 at 3AM
Cal Trans Drainage December 19, 2007 at 3AM
Water Drainage channel. Caltrans Stated at trial before Judge Tangeman "Question. Mr. Fry, Exhibit # 1475 on the screen there is the same as ...
2 weeks ago 3 views
Cal Trans Drainage December 19, 2007 at 3AM
0:30 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
Water Drainage channel. Caltrans Stated at trial before Judge Tangeman "Question. Mr. Fry, Exhibit # 1475 on the screen there is the same as ...
3 views
Caltrans District 5 Grading Debris into the Oceano Communities Drainage Channel
Caltrans District 5 Grading Debris into the Oceano Communities Drainage Channel
behind the curb where it came from. Prejudicial Error---Judge Tangeman Stated in regards to this information below that was withheld from ...
2 weeks ago 15 views InverseCondemnation1
Judge Tangeman Well # 8 January 13, 2007 In the vicinity of the drainage ...
Judge Tangeman Well # 8 January 13, 2007 In the vicinity of the drainage ...
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
3 weeks ago 49 views
Judge Tangeman Well # 8 January 13, 2007 In the vicinity of the drainage ...
1:30 February 15, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
49 views
Caltrans District 5 /OCSD FLOOD Flood MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005
Caltrans District 5 /OCSD FLOOD Flood MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
3 weeks ago 101 views
Caltrans District 5 /OCSD FLOOD Flood MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005
9:20 February 16, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
101 views
California Supreme Court--Inverse Condemnation
California Supreme Court--Inverse Condemnation
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 56 views
6:38 February 20, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
56 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 11 Caltrans District 5
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 11 Caltrans District 5
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 22 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 11 Caltrans District 5
8:08 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
22 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 121.wmv
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 121.wmv
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 10 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 121.wmv
2:55 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
10 views
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007 Flooding State Highway 1
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007 Flooding State Highway 1
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
2 weeks ago 17 views
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007 Flooding
1:16 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
17 views
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
2 weeks ago 11 views
Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 January 13, 2007
0:14 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
Judge Tangeman in his August 5, 2008 Inverse Condemnation decision decided that this Oceano Community Service District Well # 8 discharging Well ...
11 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 23.wmv
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 23.wmv
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 15 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 23.wmv
1:23 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
15 views
County of San Luis Obispo Admitting Liability At The OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, ...
County of San Luis Obispo Admitting Liability At The OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, ...
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
3 weeks ago 70 views
9:16 February 17, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
70 views
Caltrans and The County Of San Luis Obispo February 22, 2007 Storm Water Retention
Caltrans and The County Of San Luis Obispo February 22, 2007 Storm Water Retention
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
1 week ago 6 views
Caltrans and The
2:59 February 28, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
6 views
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
Caltrans caught November 26, 2008 shoveling their contaminated storm water and debris into the Oceano Communities storm water drainage channel ...
3 weeks ago 51 views
Cal Trans November 26, 2008 after Judge Tangemans Decision calling this being a good ...
1:02 February 15, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
Caltrans caught November 26, 2008 shoveling their contaminated storm water and debris into the Oceano Communities storm water drainage channel ...
51 views
Caltrans District 5 putting our public in danger---December 18, 2007
Caltrans District 5 putting our public in danger---December 18, 2007
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
1 week ago 9 views
Caltrans District 5 putting our public in danger---December 18, 2007
2:47 February 28, 2010
Comedy
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
9 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005 Caltrans and the County of San Luis Obispo
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005 Caltrans and the County of San Luis Obispo
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 17 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005 Caltrans and the
6:00 February 21, 2010
Education
surfshop1963
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
17 views
Caltrans District 5 January 4, 2008 Pumping their Storm Water to our Pacific Ocean
Caltrans District 5 January 4, 2008 Pumping their Storm Water to our Pacific Ocean
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 12 views
Caltrans District 5 January 4, 2008 Pumping their Storm Water to our
1:37 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
12 views
Caltrans District 5 Inverse Condemnation
Caltrans District 5 Inverse Condemnation
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 37 views
Caltrans District 5 Inverse Condemnation
2:04 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
37 views
Caltrans District 5 Retention Basin December 2006 instead of the Baughman Property!
Caltrans District 5 Retention Basin December 2006 instead of the Baughman Property!
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 27 views
Caltrans District 5
1:13 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
27 views
California State Highway Patrol Helping Public with Flooding May 21, 2006
California State Highway Patrol Helping Public with Flooding May 21, 2006
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
1 week ago 51 views
2:16 February 28, 2010
Comedy
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
51 views
Caltrans District 5 using State Highway 1 for Storm Water Retention
Caltrans District 5 using State Highway 1 for Storm Water Retention
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 21 views
Caltrans District 5 using State Highway 1 for Storm Water Retention
2:15 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
21 views
Caltrans Abating flooding of State Highway 1-January 4, 2008
Caltrans Abating flooding of State Highway 1-January 4, 2008
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 9 views
Caltrans Abating flooding of State Highway 1-January 4, 2008
1:00 February 22, 2010
Education
InverseCondemnation1
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
9 views
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 221.wmv
OCSD FLOOD MEETING JANUARY 10, 2005_part 221.wmv
2, 2009 Judgment Decision "Notice of Judgment" States: "Judge Tangeman determined the flooding problem was "static" for several years prior ...
2 weeks ago 13 views
Is This Inverse Condemnation? Can County's withhold evidence from discovery showing the problems in 2002 before State Highway 1 began flooding? Can Caltrans now legally Grade and shovel contaminated Storm Water and Debris into our State Drainage Channels? Can Community Service Districts legally discharge their Well water at 2500 gallons per-minute into California storm water drainage channels without doing any maintenance in regards to the sedimation this push's into our drainage systems?
This is what was said in one of the documents that the County of San Luis Obispo withheld from discovery showing what was happening in 2002.
Larry A Baughman--Owner of
"We Own a home at
"Water At The Corner Of 13th/Paso Robles/And Highway 1 Runs (Drains) Under The Railroad Tracks Across
Associate Justice Carlos R. Moreno,
Associate Justice Joyce L. Kennard,
Associate Justice Kathryn Mickle Werdegar,
Chief Justice Ronald M. George,
Associate Justice Ming W. Chin,
Associate Justice Marvin R. Baxter,
Associate Justice Carol A. Corrigan.
James J. Marchiano, Presiding Justice
Sandra L. Margulies, Associate Justice
J. Anthony Kline, Presiding Justice
Paul R.Haerle, Associate Justice
James R. Lambden, Associate Justice
James A. Richman, Associate Justice
William R. McGuiness, Administrative Presiding Justice
Stuart R. Pollak, Associate Justice
Peter J. Siggins, Associate Justice
Martin J. Jenkins, Associate Justice
Ignazio J. Ruvolo - Presiding Justice
Timothy A. Reardon, Associate Justice
Patricia K. Sepulveda, Associate Justice
Maria P. Rivera, Associate Justice
Barbara J.R. Jones, Presiding Justice
Mark B. Simons, Associate Justice
Henry E. Needham, Jr., Associate Justice
Presiding Justice Robert M. Mallano
Associate Justice Frances Rothschild
Presiding Justice Roger W. Boren
Associate Justice Kathryn Doi Todd
Associate Justice Judith M. Ashmann-Gerst
Associate Justice Victoria M. Chavez
Presiding Justice Joan D. Klein
Associate Justice H. Walter Croskey
Associate Justice Patti S. Kitching
Associate Justice Richard D. Aldrich
Presiding Justice Norman L. Epstein
Associate Justice Thomas L. Willhite, Jr.
Associate Justice Nora M. Manella
Associate Justice Steven C. Suzukawa
Presiding Justice Paul Turner
Associate Justice Orville A. Armstrong
Associate Justice Richard M. Mosk
Associate Justice Sandy R. Kriegler
Presiding Justice Arthur Gilbert
Associate Justice Kenneth R. Yegan
Associate Justice Paul H. Coffee
Associate Justice Steven Z. Perren
Presiding Justice Dennis M. Perluss
Associate Justice Fred Woods
Associate Justice Laurie D. Zelon
Associate Justice Frank Y. Jackson
Associate Justice Laurence D. Rubin
Associate Justice Madeleine Flier
Associate Justice Patricia A. Bigelow
RE: Statute of Limitations and Prejudicial Error in regards to evidence withheld from discovery by the County of San Luis Obispo Molly Thurmond, Esq. (SBN 104973)Exhibit #579 (Appendix 15) Prejudicial Error or Not? Photo/Statement Documents withheld by County Of San Luis Obispo And Railroad at trial as allowed by Judge Tangeman, as Judge Tangeman Stated "All Right" County of San Luis Obispo Causation in permits and drainage requirements on private property. OCSD and Caltrans correcting 2002 drainage complaint problems in 2002/2003 as stated in exhibit #579 Complaint, Caltrans-McKinley Testomony P. 645 and (RA exhibit #1768) changing the Statute of Limitations! Date of Stabilization!
Video Evidence presented to the Court of Caltrans grading and shoveling Conatminate Storm Water and debris into this storm water drainage channel after 2002 and their prior 30 year history of maintainging this drainage man-made drainage system! Please review the videos presented to the Court as seen on YouTube under (Inverse Condemnation)
Arthur G. Scotland
Cole Blease
Rick Sims
George Nicholson
Vance W. Raye
Rodney Davis
Harry Hull
Ronald B. Robie
M. Kathleen Butz
Tani Cantil Sakauye
Administrative Presiding Justice Judith McConnell
Associate Justice Patricia D. Benke
Associate Justice Richard D. Huffman
Associate Justice Gilbert Nares
Associate Justice Judith L. Haller
Associate Justice Alex C. McDonald
Associate Justice James A. McIntyre
Associate Justice Terry B. O'Rourke
Associate Justice Cynthia Aaron
Associate Justice Joan Irion
Presiding Justice Manuel A. Ramirez
Associate Justice Barton C. Gaut
Associate Justice Betty Ann Richli
Associate Justice Art W. McKinster
Associate Justice Thomas E. Hollenhorst
Associate Justice Jeffrey King
Associate Justice Douglas P. Miller
Presiding Justice David G. Sills
Associate Justice William F. Rylaarsdam
Associate Justice William W. Bedsworth
Associate Justice Kathleen O'Leary
Associate Justice Eileen C. Moore
Associate Justice Richard M. Aronson
Associate Justice Richard D. Fybel
Associate Justice Raymond J. Ikola
Presiding Justice James A. Ardaiz
Steven M. Vartabedian
Rebecca A. Wiseman
Bert Levy
Dennis A. Cornell
Gene M. Gomes
Betty L. Dawson
Brad R. Hill
Stephen Kane
Presiding Justice Conrad L. Rushing
Eugene M. Premo
Franklin D. Elia
Patricia Bamattre-Manoukian
Nathan D. Mihara
Richard J. McAdams
Wendy Clark Duffy
Hon. Lawrence John Appel
Hon. Kathleen M. Banke
Hon. Gordon S. Baranco
Hon. Sandra K. Bean
Hon. Morris Beatus
Hon. Gail Brewster Bereola
Hon. Jacob Blea III
Hon. Steven A. Brick
Hon. Carol S. Brosnahan
Hon. Rhonda Burgess
Hon. Kenneth Mark Burr
Hon. Joan S. Cartwright
Hon. Wynne S. Carvill
Hon. Cecilia P. Castellanos
Hon. C. Don Clay
Hon. Beverly Daniels-Greenberg
Hon. Stephen Allen Dombrink
Hon. Leopoldo E. Dorado
Hon. Robert B. Freedman
Hon. Keith H. Fudenna
Hon. Michael J. Gaffey
Hon. Delbert C. Gee
Hon. Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers
Hon. Larry J. Goodman
Hon. Evelio M. Grillo
Hon. Dan Grimmer
Hon. Brenda Fay Harbin-Forte
Hon. Roy Hashimoto
Hon. Dennis Hayashi
Hon. George C. Hernandez, Jr.
Hon. Stuart L. Hing
Hon. Jeffrey W. Horner
Hon. David E. Hunter
Hon. Joseph Hurley
Hon. Allan D. Hymer
Hon. Morris D. Jacobson
Hon. Richard O. Keller
Hon. David M. Krashna
Hon. Robert K. Kurtz
Hon. Jo-Lynne Q. Lee
Hon. Willie Lott, Jr.
Hon. Ronni B. MacLaren
Hon. Robert D. McGuiness
Hon. Dennis J. McLaughlin
Hon. Barbara J. Miller
Caltrans photos of drainage problems that Caltrans had created on East Side of State Highway 1. Taken after Oceano Community Drainage Study Questionnaire exhibit # 579 withheld from discovery. Why would Caltrans Raise State Highway 1 and not account for drainage or ponding?
Hon. Carl W. Morris
Hon. Christine K. Moruza
Hon. Kevin R. Murphy
Hon. Vernon K. Nakahara
Hon. Yolanda Neill Northridge
Hon. Carrie McIntyre Panetta
Hon. Gary M. Picetti
Hon. Stephen M. Pulido
Hon. Thomas Matthew Reardon
Hon. Gloria F. Rhynes
Hon. Frank Roesch
Hon. Jon R. Rolefson
Hon. Reginald P. Saunders
Hon. Harry R. Sheppard
Statute of Limitations with the Oceano Community Service District; drainage changes in December 2002 (RA Exhibit 1768)and prior as seen in photo exhibits below, with the Oceano Community Service Districts use of this drainage system for discharging 2500 gallons of Well water per minute into this undersized culvert blowing in and cementing debris and silt into this culvert year-around!
Flooding Photo in 2002 complained about to Caltrans and the Oceano Community Service District. fixed December 20, 2002---Caltrans and OCSD corrected this drainage problem as seen in APPELLANT’S REPLY BRIEF Exhibit # 1768 as stated by OCSD "I had to meet with Bill Bookout and a couple of guys from cal trans about the 6 inch line from well 8 that ends at the culvert by the railroad tracks. I had Dan saw off the 6 inch pipe and end it in front of the culvert so that there will be no danger of the pipe plugging debris at the entrance to the culvert." The Next OCSD log of this drainage system is February 9, 2004 before the first flooding of Oceano Nursery. OCSD States: "Then Joe had him cleaning out the drainage ditch by the railroad track down at 13th and Front Street"
Hon. Winifred Younge Smith
Hon. Julia Spain
Hon. Trina Thompson-Stanley
Hon. Jon S. Tigar
Hon. John M. True III
Hon. Alice Vilardi
Hon. Hugh A. Walker
Hon. Marshall Ivan Whitley
Hon. Patrick J. Zika
Hon. David L. DeVore
Hon. Richard K. Specchio
Hon. Susan C. Harlan
Hon. David Sargent Richmond
Hon. Stephen E. Benson
Hon. Robert A. Glusman
Hon. Gerald Hermansen
Hon. Steven J. Howell
Hon. Clare Keithley
Hon. Thomas W. Kelly
Hon. Kristen A. Lucena
Hon. Sandra L. McLean
Hon. Tamara L. Mosbarger
Hon. James F. Reilley
Hon. Barbara L. Roberts
Hon. John E. Martin
Hon. Douglas V. Mewhinney
Hon. Jeffrey A. Thompson
Hon. John H. Tiernan
Hon. Steven K. Austin
Hon. Barry Baskin
Hon. Peter A. Berger
Hon. Laurel S. Brady (Lindenbaum)
Hon. Terence L. Bruiniers
Hon. Charles B. Burch
Hon. Theresa J. Canepa
Hon. Judith S. Craddick
Hon. Joyce M. Cram
Hon. Lewis A. Davis
Hon. Jill C. Fannin
Hon. Susanne M. Fenstermacher
Hon. David B. Flinn
Hon. Barry P. Goode
Hon. Harlan G. Grossman
Hon. Lois Haight
Hon. Brian F. Haynes
Hon. Barbara C. Hinton
Hon. Joni T. Hiramoto
Hon. John William Kennedy
Hon. William M. Kolin
Hon. John T. Laettner
Hon. Leslie G. Landau
Hon. Thomas M. Maddock
Hon. Clare M. Maier
Hon. Bruce Clayton Mills
Hon. Cheryl Mills
Hon. Mary Ann O'Malley
Hon. Patricia M. Scanlon
Hon. Diana Becton Smith
Hon. George V. Spanos
Hon. Nancy Davis Stark
Hon. John H. Sugiyama
Hon. Charles S. Treat
Hon. Trevor S. White
Hon. Barbara Ann Zúñiga
Hon. William H. Follett
Hon. Robert W. Weir
Hon. Steven C. Bailey
Hon. Suzanne N. Kingsbury
Hon. Douglas C. Phimister
Hon. Daniel B. Proud
Hon. James R. Wagoner
Hon. Glenda S. Allen-Hill
Hon. Brian M. Arax
Hon. Donald S. Black
Hon. Carlos A. Cabrera
Hon. Jane Cardoza
Hon. Hilary A. Chittick
Hon. Jonathan B. Conklin
Hon. Adolfo M. Corona
Hon. Kristi Culver Kapetan
Hon. Wayne R. Ellison
Hon. Gregory T. Fain
Hon. Donald R. Franson, Jr.
Hon. Kimberly A. Gaab
Hon. David Andrew Gottlieb
Hon. Jeffrey Y. Hamilton, Jr.
Hon. W. Kent Hamlin
Hon. Arlan L. Harrell
Hon. Alvin M. Harrell, III
Hon. Gary D. Hoff
Hon. Dale Ikeda
Hon. David C. Kalemkarian
Hon. Timothy A. Kams
Hon. Jon N. Kapetan
Hon. Debra J. Kazanjian
Hon. James A. Kelley
Hon. Kimberly J. Nystrom-Geist
Hon. Robert H. Oliver
Hon. James R. Oppliger
Hon. Gary R. Orozco
Hon. Rosendo Pena, Jr.
Hon. Don Penner
Hon. James Petrucelli
Hon. Houry A. Sanderson
Hon. Edward Sarkisian, Jr.
Hon. Alan M. Simpson
Hon. M. Bruce Smith
Hon. Mark Wood Snauffer
Hon. D. Tyler Tharpe
Hon. John F. Vogt
Hon. Denise Lee Whitehead
Hon. Donald Cole Byrd
Hon. Peter B. Twede
Hon. Timothy Paul Cissna
Hon. John T. Feeney
Hon. Joyce Hinrichs
Hon. Marilyn B. Miles
Hon. Dale A. Reinholtsen
Hon. W. Bruce Watson
Hon. Christopher G. Wilson
Hon. Raymond Cota
Hon. Donal B. Donnelly
Hon. Barrett J. Foerster
Hon. Jeffrey Bruce Jones
Hon. William D. Lehman
Hon. Juan Ulloa
Hon. Christopher W. Yeager
Hon. Joseph Zimmerman
Hon. Brian Lamb
Hon. Dean Stout
Hon. Robert J. Anspach
Hon. Eric Bradshaw
Hon. Charles R. Brehmer
Hon. John R. Brownlee
Hon. Michael G. Bush
Hon. Sidney P. Chapin
Hon. L. Bryce Chase
Hon. Michael E. Dellostritto
Hon. Judith K. Dulcich
Hon. Larry Errea
Hon. Louis P. Etcheverry
Hon. Lee Phillip Felice
Hon. John L. Fielder
Hon. Gary T. Friedman
Hon. Stephen P. Gildner
Hon. Colette M. Humphrey
Hon. Gary A. Ingle
Hon. Steven M. Katz
Hon. David R. Lampe
Hon. Michael B. Lewis
Hon. Raymonda K. Marquez
Hon. John D. Oglesby
Hon. William D. Palmer
Hon. Charles B. Pfister
Hon. Craig Phillips
Hon. John S. Somers
Hon. Jon Edward Stuebbe
Hon. Robert S. Tafoya
Hon. Jerold L. Turner
Hon. Kenneth C. Twisselman II
Hon. Louie L. Vega
Hon. Arthur E. Wallace
Hon. Gary R. Witt
Hon. Cory Woodward
Hon. Lynn C. Atkinson
Hon. Steven D. Barnes
Hon. Louis F. Bissig
Hon. Thomas DeSantos
Hon. James LaPorte
Hon. George Orndoff
Hon. Peter M. Schultz
Hon. Stephen Owen Hedstrom
Hon. David W. Herrick
Hon. Arthur H. Mann
Hon. Richard C. Martin
Hon. Stephen Douglas Bradbury
Hon. F. Donald Sokol
Hon. Michael D. Abzug
Hon. Richard A. Adler
Hon. Dennis A. Aichroth
Hon. Gregory Wilson Alarcon
Hon. Deborah B. Andrews
Hon. Robert P. Applegate
Hon. Conrad Richard Aragon
Hon. Mark S. Arnold
Hon. Monica Bachner
Hon. Paul A. Bacigalupo
Hon. Henry T. Barela
Hon. Antonio Barreto, Jr.
Hon. William P. Barry
Hon. Candace J. Beason
Hon. Teresa A. Beaudet
Hon. Mitchell L. Beckloff
Hon. Martha Bellinger
Hon. Helen Bendix
Hon. Elihu M. Berle
Hon. Margaret Miller Bernal
Hon. James N. Bianco
Hon. Joseph S. Biderman
Hon. William J. Birney
Hon. Steven D. Blades
Hon. Kathleen Blanchard
Hon. Stanley Blumenfeld
Hon. Aviva K. Bobb
Hon. Terry A. Bork
Hon. Bob S. Bowers, Jr.
Hon. James R. Brandlin
Hon. Joseph A. Brandolino
Hon. Kevin Clement Brazile
Hon. David C. Brougham
Hon. Irma J. Brown
Hon. Kevin L. Brown
Hon. Leslie E. Brown
Hon. Soussan G. Bruguera
Hon. Susan Bryant-Deason
Hon. Daniel J. Buckley
Hon. Mike Camacho
Hon. Michael D. Carter
Hon. James C. Chalfant
Hon. Judith L. Champagne
Hon. Victoria G. Chaney
Hon. Victor E. Chavez
Hon. John Joseph Cheroske
Hon. William R. Chidsey, Jr.
Hon. Judith C. Chirlin
Hon. Lawrence Cho
Hon. Deborah L. Christian
Hon. Charles (Carlos) Chung
Hon. Lisa Mangay Chung
Hon. Edmund Willcox Clarke, Jr.
Hon. Charles Q. Clay III
Hon. Suzette Clover
Hon. Ronald S. Coen
Hon. Lisa Hart Cole
Hon. Debra Cole-Hall
Hon. Joan Comparet-Cassani
Hon. Patrick Connolly
Hon. Jacqueline A. Connor
Hon. Huey P. Cotton, Jr.
Hon. Michael A. Cowell
Hon. Janice Claire Croft
Hon. David S. Cunningham, III
Hon. J. Stephen Czuleger
Hon. James R. Dabney
Hon. Gary E. Daigh
Hon. Ralph W. Dau
Hon. Joseph F. De Vanon, Jr.
Hon. Roy G. Delgado
Hon. Ellen Carol DeShazer
Hon. Rudolph A. Diaz
Hon. Kathleen O. Diesman
Hon. Joseph E. DiLoreto
Hon. Gregory A. Dohi
Hon. Juan Carlos Dominguez
Hon. Marguerite D. Downing
Hon. John T. Doyle
Hon. John P. Doyle
Hon. Maureen Duffy-Lewis
Hon. Robert A. Dukes
Hon. James R. Dunn
Hon. Leslie A. Dunn
Hon. Anita H. Dymant
Hon. Lee Smalley Edmon
Hon. Drew E. Edwards
Hon. Anne Harwood Egerton
Hon. Emilie Harris Elias
Hon. Laura C. Ellison
Hon. Carol Williams Elswick
Hon. Mildred Escobedo
Hon. Peter Paul Espinoza
Hon. Christopher Estes
Hon. William F. Fahey
Hon. Dewey Lawes Falcone
Hon. Thomas Falls
Hon. John P. Farrell
Hon. Elizabeth R. Feffer
Hon. Daniel B. Feldstern
Hon. Edward A. Ferns
Hon. Gary J. Ferrari
Hon. Eudon Ferrell
Hon. Gail Ruderman Feuer
Hon. Larry P. Fidler
Hon. Kelvin D. Filer
Hon. John S. Fisher
Hon. Tia G. Fisher
Hon. Lori A. Fournier
Hon. Elden S. Fox
Hon. Josh M. Fredricks
Hon. Kenneth R. Freeman
Hon. Graciela L. Freixes
Hon. Terry B. Friedman
Hon. Richard L. Fruin, Jr.
Hon. Fred J. Fujioka
Hon. Brian F. Gasdia
Hon. David B. Gelfound
Hon. George Genesta
Hon. Harvey Giss
Hon. Bert Glennon, Jr.
Hon. Hank Goldberg
Hon. Donna Fields Goldstein
Hon. Gus Gomez
Hon. Allan J. Goodman
Hon. Carol Boas Goodson
Hon. Richard M. Goul
Hon. Dudley W. Gray II
Hon. Lesley C. Green
Hon. Terry A. Green
Hon. Victor H. Greenberg
Hon. Elizabeth A. Grimes
Hon. Donna Groman
Hon. Paul Gutman
Hon. Hector M. Guzman
Hon. Gary R. Hahn
Hon. James K. Hahn
Hon. Howard L. Halm
Hon. Leland B. Harris
Hon. Michael B. Harwin
Hon. Marcelita V. Haynes
Hon. Rex Heeseman
Hon. Patrick J. Hegarty
Hon. John L. Henning
Hon. Margaret Henry
Hon. Martin Larry Herscovitz
Hon. Robert Leslie Hess
Hon. Philip H. Hickok
Hon. Robert J. Higa
Hon. William F. Highberger
Hon. Bob T. Hight
Hon. Alice C. Hill
Hon. Christina L. Hill
Hon. Deirdre H. Hill
Hon. Ernest M. Hiroshige
Hon. Amy D. Hogue
Hon. Rose Hom
Hon. Alan B. Honeycutt
Hon. Charles E. Horan
Hon. H. Chester Horn, Jr.
Hon. Mary Thornton House
Hon. Eleanor J. Hunter
Hon. John H. Ing
Hon. Maral Injejikian
Hon. Lance A. Ito
Hon. Roger T. Ito
Hon. Arthur Jean
Hon. Michael V. Jesic
Hon. Samantha P. Jessner
Hon. Barbara R. Johnson
Hon. Frank J. Johnson
Hon. Jane L. Johnson
Hon. Jerry E. Johnson
Hon. Michael M. Johnson
Hon. Ann I. Jones
Hon. Mark A. Juhas
Hon. Ray G. Jurado
Hon. James A. Kaddo
Hon. Craig D. Karlan
Hon. Andrew C. Kauffman
Hon. Michael K. Kellogg
Hon. Richard S. Kemalyan
Hon. Holly E. Kendig
Hon. Kathleen Kennedy
Hon. Gregory Keosian
Hon. Karla D. Kerlin
Hon. Abraham Khan
Hon. Mark C. Kim
Hon. Richard H. Kirschner
Hon. Steven J. Kleifield
Hon. Brett Carroll Klein
Hon. Clifford Klein
Hon. Ross M. Klein
Hon. Wendy L. Kohn
Hon. Marlene A. Kristovich
Hon. John A. Kronstadt
Hon. Carolyn B. Kuhl
Hon. Sanjay T. Kumar
Hon. Ruth Ann Kwan
Hon. Owen Lee Kwong
Hon. Bernie C. LaForteza
Hon. Marvin M. Lager
Hon. Dennis J. Landin
Hon. Michael Allen Latin
Hon. Luis A. Lavin
Hon. Linda K. Lefkowitz
Hon. Lisa B. Lench
Hon. Michael I. Levanas
Hon. Jan Greenberg Levine
Hon. Arthur M. Lew
Hon. Thomas T. Lewis
Hon. Peter D. Lichtman
Hon. Michael P. Linfield
Hon. Elizabeth Ann Lippitt
Hon. George G. Lomeli
Hon. Daniel S. Lopez
Hon. Gilbert M. Lopez
Hon. Susan Lopez-Giss
Hon. John David Lord
Hon. Daniel J. Lowenthal
Hon. Elaine Lu
Hon. Ana Maria Luna
Hon. Dalila C. Lyons
Hon. Kenji Machida
Hon. Lyle Michael MacKenzie
Hon. Malcolm H. Mackey
Hon. William A. MacLaughlin
Hon. Patrick T. Madden
Hon. Katherine Mader
Hon. Gregg Marcus
Hon. Stephen A. Marcus
Hon. Bruce F. Marrs
Hon. Robert M. Martinez
Hon. Laura A. Matz
Hon. Philip K. Mautino
Hon. Darrell S. Mavis
Hon. Charles W. McCoy, Jr.
Hon. Patti Jo McKay
Hon. Thomas I. McKnew, Jr.
Hon. Peter Joseph Meeka
Hon. Barbara Ann Meiers
Hon. John Vernon Meigs
Hon. Louis M. Meisinger
Hon. Hilleri G. Merritt
Hon. Judith L. Meyer
Hon. Patrick Timothy Meyers
Hon. Rita J. Miller
Hon. Robin Miller Sloan
Hon. Scott T. Millington
Hon. David Sherman Milton
Hon. Michael S. Mink
Hon. David L. Minning
Hon. R. Bruce Minto
Hon. Lawrence J. Mira
Hon. Peter J. Mirich
Hon. Craig J. Mitchell
Hon. Daviann L. Mitchell
Hon. Anthony J. Mohr
Hon. Mark V. Mooney
Hon. Edward B. Moreton, Jr.
Hon. Jared D. Moses
Hon. Aurelio Munoz
Hon. Daniel S. Murphy
Hon. Mary Ann Murphy
Hon. Richard E. Naranjo
Hon. Lloyd M. Nash
Hon. Michael Nash
Hon. Maren E. Nelson
Hon. Mark G. Nelson, Sr.
Hon. Nancy L. Newman
Hon. Jacqueline H. Nguyen
Hon. Patricia Nieto
Hon. Cary H. Nishimoto
Hon. Karen Joy Nudell
Hon. Beverly Reid O'Connell
Hon. Joanne B. O'Donnell
Hon. Michael J. O'Gara
Hon. Robert P. O'Neill
Hon. Ricardo R. Ocampo
Hon. Steven D. Ogden
Hon. Sam Ohta
Hon. Vincent H. Okamoto
Hon. Dan Thomas Oki
Hon. Margaret L. Oldendorf
Hon. Charlaine F. Olmedo
Hon. Lynn D. Olson
Hon. Tomson T. Ong
Hon. Rafael A. Ongkeko
Hon. Benny C. Osorio
Hon. James D. Otto
Hon. Yvette M. Palazuelos
Hon. Charles F. Palmer
Hon. Michael E. Pastor
Hon. Roy L. Paul
Hon. Amy M. Pellman
Hon. Robert J. Perry
Hon. Stephen P. Pfahler
Hon. James B. Pierce
Hon. Burt Pines
Hon. Jan A. Pluim
Hon. William R. Pounders
Hon. Laura F. Priver
Hon. Daniel P. Ramirez
Hon. Curtis B. Rappé
Hon. Cynthia Rayvis
Hon. Mel Red Recana
Hon. Carol H. Rehm, Jr.
Hon. John H. Reid
Hon. Marsha N. Revel
Hon. Dorothy B. Reyes
Hon. Randy Rhodes
Hon. Alex Ricciardulli
Hon. Stuart M. Rice
Hon. Craig Richman
Hon. Richard Edward Rico
Hon. Georgina T. Rizk
Hon. Morton Rochman
Hon. Jesus I. Rodriguez
Hon. Randolph Rogers
Hon. Richard R. Romero
Hon. Ronald H. Rose
Hon. Gerald Rosenberg
Hon. Michelle R. Rosenblatt
Hon. Alan S. Rosenfield
Hon. Frederick Rotenberg
Hon. Rand Steven Rubin
Hon. Thomas Rubinson
Hon. William C. Ryan
Hon. Tammy Chung Ryu
Hon. Raul Anthony Sahagun
Hon. Deborah L. Sanchez
Hon. Yvonne T. Sanchez
Hon. Teresa Sanchez-Gordon
Hon. Jose I. Sandoval
Hon. Melvin D. Sandvig
Hon. Steven P. Sanora
Hon. Ray A. Santana
Hon. Cesar C. Sarmiento
Hon. Stephanie Sautner
Hon. Barbara Marie Scheper
Hon. Patricia M. Schnegg
Hon. Robert J. Schuit
Hon. Keith L. Schwartz
Hon. Teri Schwartz
Hon. R. Carlton Seaver
Hon. Ramona G. See
Hon. John Segal
Hon. Frederick C. Shaller
Hon. Norman J. Shapiro
Hon. Charles D. Sheldon
Hon. John P. Shook
Hon. Dorothy L. Shubin
Hon. Harvey A. Silberman
Hon. Shari Kreisler Silver
Hon. B. Scott Silverman
Hon. Jessica Perrin Silvers
Hon. C. Edward Simpson
Hon. Zaven V. Sinanian
Hon. Ronald V. Skyers
Hon. Terry Lee Smerling
Hon. Spurgeon E. Smith
Hon. Ronald M. Sohigian
Hon. Thomas R. Sokolov
Hon. Michael C. Solner
Hon. Kathryn A. Solorzano
Hon. Douglas W. Sortino
Hon. David Sotelo
Hon. Philip L. Soto
Hon. Susan M. Speer
Hon. James A. Steele
Hon. Marjorie S. Steinberg
Hon. William N. Sterling
Hon. Michael L. Stern
Hon. Emily A. Stevens
Hon. William D. Stewart
Hon. Charles W. Stoll
Hon. Richard A. Stone
Hon. Maria E. Stratton
Hon. Mary H. Strobel
Hon. David W. Stuart
Hon. Leslie A. Swain
Hon. Jon R. Takasugi
Hon. Norman Perry Tarle
Hon. Eric C. Taylor
Hon. Michael Terrell
Hon. Sandra Ann Thompson
Hon. Bobbi Tillmon
Hon. Leland H. Tipton
Hon. Patricia Jo Titus
Hon. John A. Torribio
Hon. Rolf Michael Treu
Hon. Michael Anthony Tynan
Hon. Cynthia L. Ulfig
Hon. Carlos A. Uranga
Hon. Steven R. Van Sicklen
Hon. Judith A. Vander Lans
Hon. Robert C. Vanderet
Hon. Craig Elliott Veals
Hon. Michael P. Vicencia
Hon. Michael Villalobos
Hon. Mary Lou Villar
Hon. Richard F. Walmark
Hon. Fred N. Wapner
Hon. Fumiko Hachiya Wasserman
Hon. Allen Joseph Webster, Jr.
Hon. Elia Weinbach
Hon. Debre Katz Weintraub
Hon. Lauren Weis Birnstein
Hon. William R. Weisman
Hon. David S. Wesley
Hon. Carl J. West
Hon. Diana M. Wheatley
Hon. Elizabeth Allen White
Hon. Thomas R. White
Hon. Gloria L. White-Brown
Hon. Melissa N. Widdifield
Hon. John Shepard Wiley, Jr.
Hon. William G. Willett
Hon. Mark E. Windham
Hon. Richard B. Wolfe
Hon. Victor L. Wright
Hon. David P. Yaffe
Hon. Brian C. Yep
Hon. Mark A. Young
Hon. Geanene M. Yriarte
Hon. Hayden A. Zacky
Hon. Daniel Zeke Zeidler
Hon. Thomas L. Bender
Hon. Jennifer R.S. Detjen
Hon. D. Lynn Jones
Hon. Ernest J. LiCalsi
Hon. Edward P. Moffat II
Hon. James E. Oakley
Hon. Mitchell C. Rigby
Hon. Charles A. Wieland
Hon. Eric C. Wyatt
Hon. Verna Alana Adams
Hon. Terrence R. Boren
Hon. Faye D'Opal
Hon. Michael B. Dufficy
Hon. Lynn Duryee
Hon. Paul M. Haakenson
Hon. James R. Ritchie
Hon. Kelly V. Simmons
Hon. John A. Sutro, Jr.
Hon. Wayne R. Parrish
Hon. F. Dana Walton
Hon. John A. Behnke
Hon. Clayton L. Brennan
Hon. Ronald Brown
Hon. Richard James Henderson
Hon. Leonard J. LaCasse
Hon. Jonathan M. Lehan
Hon. Cindee F. Mayfield
Hon. David E. Nelson
Hon. Carol K. Ash
Hon. Frank Dougherty
Hon. Hugh Flanagan
Hon. Marc A. Garcia
Hon. Ronald W. Hansen
Hon. John D. Kirihara
Hon. Brian L. McCabe
Hon. Donald J. Proietti
Hon. Francis W. Barclay
Hon. Stanley L. Eller
Hon. Edward Forstenzer
Hon. Marla O. Anderson
Hon. Robert A. Burlison
Hon. Richard M. Curtis
Hon. Susan M. Dauphiné
Hon. Terrance R. Duncan
Hon. Adrienne M. Grover
Hon. Larry E. Hayes
Hon. Mark E. Hood
Hon. Efren N. Iglesia
Hon. Kay T. Kingsley
Hon. Sam Lavorato, Jr.
Hon. Albert H. Maldonado
Hon. Robert A. O'Farrell
Hon. Jonathan R. Price
Hon. Timothy P. Roberts
Hon. Russell D. Scott
Hon. Lydia M. Villarreal
Hon. Thomas W. Wills
Hon. Mark Boessenecker
Hon. Raymond A. Guadagni
Hon. Stephen Thomas Kroyer
Hon. Diane M. Price
Hon. Rodney G. Stone
Hon. Francisca P. Tisher
Hon. Thomas M. Anderson
Hon. Sean P. Dowling
Hon. Candace S. Heidelberger
Hon. C. Anders Holmer
Hon. Julie A. McManus
Hon. Robert Lynn Tamietti
Hon. John S. Adams
Hon. Frederick P. Aguirre
Hon. Margaret R. Anderson
Hon. Matthew S. Anderson
Hon. Gail A. Andler
Hon. Andrew P. Banks
Hon. Ronald Lawrence Bauer
Hon. Carlton P. Biggs
Hon. Thomas James Borris
Hon. Francisco P. Briseno
Hon. Steven D. Bromberg
Hon. Jacki C. Brown
Hon. Debra D. Carrillo
Hon. Marjorie Laird Carter
Hon. David R. Chaffee
Hon. Thierry Patrick Colaw
Hon. John Dorsey Conley
Hon. Corey Scott Cramin
Hon. Donna L. Crandall
Hon. James J. Di Cesare
Hon. Daniel J. Didier
Hon. Patrick H. Donahue
Hon. Kim Garlin Dunning
Hon. William Lee Evans
Hon. Frank F. Fasel
Hon. Sheila B. Fell
Hon. Francisco F. Firmat
Hon. Jonathan S. Fish
Hon. John L. Flynn III
Hon. William R. Froeberg
Hon. Donald F. Gaffney
Hon. Robert C. Gannon
Hon. John C. Gastelum
Hon. Stephanie George
Hon. Geoffrey T. Glass
Hon. Thomas M. Goethals
Hon. Sheila F. Hanson
Hon. Douglas Hatchimonji
Hon. W. Michael Hayes
Hon. David A. Hoffer
Hon. Frederick Paul Horn
Hon. Kim R. Hubbard
Hon. Derek W. Hunt
Hon. Robert Byron Hutson
Hon. Lance P. Jensen
Hon. Derek Guy Johnson
Hon. Gerald G. Johnston
Hon. Gregory W. Jones
Hon. M. Marc Kelly
Hon. Richard M. King
Hon. Carolyn Kirkwood
Hon. Ronald P. Kreber
Hon. Erick L. Larsh
Hon. Caryl A. Lee
Hon. Gregory H. Lewis
Hon. Wendy Lindley
Hon. Brett G. London
Hon. Kazuharu Makino
Hon. Charles Margines
Hon. James Patrick Marion
Hon. Joy Wiesenfeld Markman
Hon. Linda S. Marks
Hon. Michael S. McCartin
Hon. David T. McEachen
Hon. Daniel Barrett McNerney
Hon. Kimberly Menninger
Hon. Mark S. Millard
Hon. Franz E. Miller
Hon. Linda Lancet Miller
Hon. Jamoa Athena Moberly
Hon. William Michael Monroe
Hon. Robert James Moss
Hon. Gregory Munoz
Hon. Kirk H. Nakamura
Hon. Michael J. Naughton
Hon. John Nho Trong Nguyen
Hon. Gary S. Paer
Hon. Steven L. Perk
Hon. Nancy A. Pollard
Hon. Peter J. Polos
Hon. James H. Poole
Hon. Gregg L. Prickett
Hon. Roger B. Robbins
Hon. Karen L. Robinson
Hon. Craig E. Robison
Hon. Luis A. Rodriguez
Hon. James Edward Rogan
Hon. Glenda Sanders
Hon. Salvador Sarmiento
Hon. Mary Fingal Schulte
Hon. B. Tam Nomoto Schumann
Hon. Randall J. Sherman
Hon. Claudia J. Silbar
Hon. Carla M. Singer
Hon. Clay M. Smith
Hon. Richard W. Stanford, Jr.
Hon. Nancy Wieben Stock
Hon. James A. Stotler
Hon. Elaine Streger
Hon. Stephen J. Sundvold
Hon. David A. Thompson
Hon. Nicholas S. Thompson
Hon. Richard Francis Toohey
Hon. Josephine S. Tucker
Hon. David C. Velasquez
Hon. James L. Waltz
Hon. John M. Watson
Hon. Randell L. Wilkinson
Hon. Mark S. Curry
Hon. Larry D. Gaddis
Hon. Eugene S. Gini, Jr.
Hon. Frances A. Kearney
Hon. Robert P. McElhany
Hon. Colleen M. Nichols
Hon. Joseph O'Flaherty
Hon. Jeffrey Penney
Hon. Alan V. Pineschi
Hon. Charles D. Wachob
Hon. Janet Hilde
Hon. Ira R. Kaufman
Hon. Irma Poole Asberry
Hon. Angel M. Bermudez
Hon. Thomas H. Cahraman
Hon. Sarah Adams Christian
Hon. Judith C. Clark
Hon. Carol D. Codrington
Hon. Mark Ashton Cope
Hon. James A. Cox
Hon. Graham Anderson Cribbs
Hon. Frederick Paul Dickerson III
Hon. Michael B. Donner
Hon. David B. Downing
Hon. Becky Lynn Dugan
Hon. Sherrill A. Ellsworth
Hon. Richard A. Erwood
Hon. John G. Evans
Hon. Richard T. Fields
Hon. Mac R. Fisher
Hon. Timothy F. Freer
Hon. James S. Hawkins
Hon. Jorge C. Hernandez
Hon. Helios (Joe) Hernandez II
Hon. Harold W. Hopp
Hon. Charles J. Koosed
Hon. Jean Pfeiffer Leonard
Hon. Michele D. Levine
Hon. L. Jackson Lucky IV
Hon. Roger A. Luebs
Hon. Patrick F. Magers
Hon. Mark A. Mandio
Hon. Robert J. McIntyre
Hon. John D. Molloy
Hon. John M. Monterosso
Hon. W. Charles Morgan
Hon. Mark E. Petersen
Hon. Jeffrey Prevost
Hon. Craig Riemer
Hon. Michael J. Rushton
Hon. Bernard Schwartz
Hon. Christopher J. Sheldon
Hon. Elisabeth Sichel
Hon. Charles E. Stafford, Jr.
Hon. Christian F. Thierbach
Hon. Gary B. Tranbarger
Hon. Gloria Connor Trask
Hon. Anthony R. Villalobos
Hon. Sharon J. Waters
Hon. Douglas E. Weathers
Hon. Edward D. Webster
Hon. Dale R. Wells
Hon. Randall D. White
Hon. Albert J. Wojcik
Hon. Paul E. Zellerbach
Hon. David W. Abbott
Hon. Eugene L. Balonon
Hon. Jerilyn L. Borack
Hon. Stacy Boulware Eurie
Hon. David I. Brown
Hon. Trena H. Burger-Plavan
Hon. Raymond M. Cadei
Hon. Roland L. Candee
Hon. Shelleyanne W. L. Chang
Hon. Lloyd G. Connelly
Hon. Kevin R. Culhane
Hon. David F. De Alba
Hon. Elena J. Duarte
Hon. Laurie M. Earl
Hon. Greta Curtis Fall
Hon. Timothy M. Frawley
Hon. Michael T. Garcia
Hon. Matthew J. Gary
Hon. Maryanne G. Gilliard
Hon. Richard H. Gilmour
Hon. Helena R. Gweon
Hon. Judy Holzer Hersher
Hon. Robert C. Hight
Hon. Russell L. Hom
Hon. Michael P. Kenny
Hon. Marjorie Koller
Hon. James L. Long
Hon. Sharon A. Lueras
Hon. Patrick Marlette
Hon. Peter J. McBrien
Hon. Kevin J. McCormick
Hon. James E. McFetridge
Hon. Loren E. McMaster
Hon. Cheryl Chun Meegan
Hon. James M. Mize
Hon. Gary S. Mullen
Hon. Troy L. Nunley
Hon. Delbert W. Oros
Hon. Alan G. Perkins
Hon. Kenneth G. Peterson
Hon. Jaime R. Román
Hon. Michael A. Savage
Hon. Ernest W. Sawtelle
Hon. Pamela L. Smith-Steward
Hon. Allen H. Sumner
Hon. Michael W. Sweet
Hon. Raoul M. Thorbourne
Hon. Robert M. Twiss
Hon. Brian R. Van Camp
Hon. Emily E. Vasquez
Hon. Michael G. Virga
Hon. Steve W. White
Hon. John P. Winn
Hon. Gerrit W. Wood
Hon. Steven R. Sanders
Hon. Harry J. Tobias
Hon. Larry W. Allen
Hon. Donald R. Alvarez
Hon. Kenneth Barr
Hon. Teresa M. Bennett
Hon. Colin J. Bilash
Hon. Joseph R. Brisco
Hon. Kyle S. Brodie
Hon. Gerard S. Brown
Hon. Ronald M. Christianson
Hon. David S. Cohn
Hon. Rodney A. Cortez
Hon. Keith D. Davis
Hon. Michael M. Dest
Hon. Douglas M. Elwell
Hon. W. Robert Fawke
Hon. Jon D. Ferguson
Hon. Jules E. Fleuret
Hon. Bryan F. Foster
Hon. Janet M. Frangie
Hon. Mary E. Fuller
Hon. Donna G. Garza
Hon. Thomas S. Garza
Hon. John B. Gibson
Hon. J. Michael Gunn
Hon. Raymond L. Haight III
Hon. Arthur Harrison
Hon. Cara D. Hutson
Hon. Cheryl C. Kersey
Hon. Robert J. Lemkau
Hon. Michael R. Libutti
Hon. Cynthia Ann Ludvigsen
Hon. Steve Malone
Hon. Steven A. Mapes
Hon. Christopher B. Marshall
Hon. John N. Martin
Hon. J. David Mazurek
Hon. Brigid McCann
Hon. Brian S. McCarville
Hon. James C. McGuire
Hon. Dwight W. Moore
Hon. Miriam Ivy Morton
Hon. Eric M. Nakata
Hon. Gilbert G. Ochoa
Hon. Annemarie G. Pace
Hon. John M. Pacheco
Hon. Elia V. Pirozzi
Hon. Barry L. Plotkin
Hon. William Jefferson Powell IV
Hon. Margaret A. Powers
Hon. Stanford E. Reichert
Hon. Tara Reilly
Hon. Shahla S. Sabet
Hon. Michael A. Sachs
Hon. Stephan G. Saleson
Hon. Brian D. Saunders
Hon. Wilfred J. Schneider, Jr.
Hon. Marsha Slough
Hon. Michael A. Smith
Hon. Gregory S. Tavill
Hon. John M. Tomberlin
Hon. Ingrid Adamson Uhler
Hon. Raymond Paul Van Stockum
Hon. John P. Vander Feer
Hon. John P. Wade
Hon. Christopher J. Warner
Hon. James Michael Welch
Hon. Katrina West
Hon. Linda M. Wilde
Hon. David A. Williams
Hon. Harold T. Wilson, Jr.
Hon. Lorna A. Alksne
Hon. Edward P. Allard III
Hon. Carlos O. Armour
Hon. Katherine A. Bacal
Hon. Jeffrey B. Barton
Hon. Cynthia A. Bashant
Hon. Laura J. Birkmeyer
Hon. Jay M. Bloom
Hon. Jeffrey S. Bostwick
Hon. Blaine K. Bowman
Hon. Joseph P. Brannigan
Hon. David G. Brown
Hon. Frank A. Brown
Hon. Desiree A. Bruce-Lyle
Hon. Gary M. Bubis
Hon. Carolyn M. Caietti
Hon. Yvonne Esperanza Campos
Hon. William S. Cannon
Hon. Timothy M. Casserly
Hon. George W. Clarke
Hon. Richard G. Cline
Hon. Robert C. Coates
Hon. Patricia K. Cookson
Hon. Gonzalo P. Curiel
Hon. Robert P. Dahlquist
Hon. David J. Danielsen
Hon. William S. Dato
Hon. John L. Davidson
Hon. Peter C. Deddeh
Hon. Steven R. Denton
Hon. Francis M. Devaney
Hon. John S. Einhorn
Hon. Harry M. Elias
Hon. Kevin A. Enright
Hon. Charles W. Ervin
Hon. Ana L. España
Hon. Herbert J. Exarhos
Hon. Eugenia A. Eyherabide
Hon. Lisa Foster
Hon. Jeffrey F. Fraser
Hon. Ronald F. Frazier
Hon. Peter L. Gallagher
Hon. Patricia Garcia
Hon. William C. Gentry, Jr.
Hon. Charles R. Gill
Hon. David M. Gill
Hon. Christine K. Goldsmith
Hon. Daniel B. Goldstein
Hon. Alvin E. Green, Jr.
Hon. Garry G. Haehnle
Hon. Laura W. Halgren
Hon. Maureen F. Hallahan
Hon. Louis R. Hanoian
Hon. Albert T. Harutunian III
Hon. Charles R. Hayes
Hon. Judith F. Hayes
Hon. Esteban Hernández
Hon. Marshall Y. Hockett
Hon. Yuri Hofmann
Hon. Susan D. Huguenor
Hon. Tamila E. Ipema
Hon. Carol Isackson
Hon. Gerald C. Jessop
Hon. Gale E. Kaneshiro
Hon. Aaron H. Katz
Hon. Robert J. Kearney
Hon. Julia Craig Kelety
Hon. K. Michael Kirkman
Hon. Evan P. Kirvin
Hon. Roger W. Krauel
Hon. William H. Kronberger
Hon. Melinda J. Lasater
Hon. Joan M. Lewis
Hon. Kathleen M. Lewis
Hon. Lantz Lewis
Hon. Frederic L. Link
Hon. Robert C. Longstreth
Hon. Earl H. Maas III
Hon. Frederick Maguire
Hon. Runston G. Maino
Hon. William H. McAdam, Jr.
Hon. William J. McGrath, Jr.
Hon. John S. Meyer
Hon. Amalia L. Meza
Hon. Richard E. Mills
Hon. Dwayne K. Moring
Hon. William R. Nevitt, Jr.
Hon. Thomas P. Nugent
Hon. Robert F. O'Neill
Hon. David B. Oberholtzer
Hon. Adrienne A. Orfield
Hon. Michael B. Orfield
Hon. Laura H. Parsky
Hon. Gregory W. Pollack
Hon. Harry L. Powazek
Hon. Ronald S. Prager
Hon. Allan J. Preckel
Hon. Joel M. Pressman
Hon. Linda B. Quinn
Hon. Charles G. Rogers
Hon. David M. Rubin
Hon. DeAnn M. Salcido
Hon. Lisa C. Schall
Hon. Polly H. Shamoon
Hon. Roderick Ward Shelton
Hon. Howard H. Shore
Hon. Michael T. Smyth
Hon. Kenneth K. So
Hon. Stephanie Sontag
Hon. Jacqueline M. Stern
Hon. Richard E. L. Strauss
Hon. Eddie C. Sturgeon
Hon. Ronald L. Styn
Hon. David M. Szumowski
Hon. Timothy B. Taylor
Hon. John M. Thompson
Hon. Timothy W. Tower
Hon. Randa Trapp
Hon. Robert J. Trentacosta
Hon. Leo Valentine, Jr.
Hon. Luis R. Vargas
Hon. Sim von Kalinowski
Hon. Timothy R. Walsh
Hon. Theodore M. Weathers
Hon. Joan P. Weber
Hon. Kerry Wells
Hon. Richard S. Whitney
Hon. Browder A. Willis III
Hon. Joel R. Wohlfeil
Hon. Margie G. Woods
Hon. David L. Ballati
Hon. Jerome T. Benson
Hon. Suzanne Ramos Bolanos
Hon. Anne Bouliane
Hon. Susan M. Breall
Hon. Peter J. Busch
Hon. Ellen Chaitin
Hon. Bruce E. Chan
Hon. Nancy L. Davis
Hon. John E. Dearman
Hon. Gail Dekreon
Hon. Robert L. Dondero
Hon. Wallace P. Douglass
Hon. Katherine A. Feinstein
Hon. Loretta M. Giorgi
Hon. Ernest H. Goldsmith
Hon. Charles F. Haines
Hon. Donna J. Hitchens
Hon. Teri L. Jackson
Hon. Harold E. Kahn
Hon. Curtis E.A. Karnow
Hon. Kathleen A. Kelly
Hon. Charlene P. Kiesselbach
Hon. Richard A. Kramer
Hon. Newton J. Lam
Hon. Cynthia Ming-Mei Lee
Hon. Donna Alyson Little
Hon. Patrick J. Mahoney
Hon. Tomar Mason
Hon. Anne-Christine Massullo
Hon. James J. McBride
Hon. Kevin M. McCarthy
Hon. Marla J. Miller
Hon. Donald S. Mitchell
Hon. Mary Carolyn Morgan
Hon. John E. Munter
Hon. Ronald Evans Quidachay
Hon. A. James Robertson II
Hon. Gerardo C. Sandoval
Hon. Lillian Kwok Sing
Hon. John Kennedy Stewart
Hon. Donald J. Sullivan
Hon. Julie M. Tang
Hon. Ksenia Tsenin
Hon. Diane Elan Wick
Hon. Mary E. Wiss
Hon. Garrett L. Wong
Hon. Charlotte Walter Woolard
Hon. Carol Yaggy
Hon. George J. Abdallah, Jr.
Hon. Antonino J. Agbayani
Hon. Jose L. Alva
Hon. Robin Appel
Hon. Michael D. Coughlan
Hon. Cinda Sanchez Fox
Hon. Bernard J. Garber
Hon. Richard J. Guiliani
Hon. Thomas M. Harrington
Hon. Lesley D. Holland
Hon. Carter P. Holly
Hon. Elizabeth Humphreys
Hon. Barbara A. Kronlund
Hon. Linda L. Lofthus
Hon. Anthony P. Lucaccini
Hon. Richard M. Mallett
Hon. Bobby W. McNatt
Hon. William J. Murray, Jr.
Hon. Ronald A. Northup
Hon. Charlotte J. Orcutt
Hon. Roger Ross
Hon. Franklin M. Stephenson
Hon. F. Clark Sueyres, Jr.
Hon. Lauren P. Thomasson
Hon. Phillip Urie
Hon. Terrence R. Van Oss
Hon. Xapuri Villapudua
Hon. Richard Vlavianos
Hon. David P. Warner
Hon. Earle Jeffrey Burke
Hon. Charles S. Crandall
Hon. Jac A. Crawford
Hon. Michael L. Duffy
Hon. Teresa Estrada-Mullaney
Hon. Ginger E. Garrett
Hon. Dodie A. Harman
Hon. Barry T. LaBarbera
Hon. Roger T. Picquet
Hon. Martin J. Tangeman
Hon. John A. Trice
Hon. Joseph E. Bergeron
Hon. Gerald J. Buchwald
Hon. Clifford V. Cretan
Hon. Marta S. Diaz
Hon. Steven L. Dylina
Hon. H. James Ellis
Hon. Susan I. Etezadi
Hon. Robert D. Foiles
Hon. Mark R. Forcum
Hon. Don R. Franchi
Hon. Beth Labson Freeman
Hon. Norman J. Gatzert
Hon. John L. Grandsaert
Hon. Stephen M. Hall
Hon. Carl W. Holm
Hon. Jonathan Karesh
Hon. Elizabeth Lee
Hon. Richard Clifton Livermore
Hon. Barbara J. Mallach
Hon. George A. Miram
Hon. Carol L. Mittlesteadt
Hon. Lisa A. Novak
Hon. Craig L. Parsons
Hon. Rosemary Pfeiffer
Hon. Joseph C. Scott
Hon. Marie S. Weiner
Hon. Thomas R. Adams
Hon. Thomas P. Anderle
Hon. Clifford R. Anderson III
Hon. Jed Beebe
Hon. James W. Brown
Hon. Edward H. Bullard
Hon. Jean M. Dandona
Hon. Denise de Bellefeuille
Hon. George C. Eskin
Hon. Rogelio R. Flores
Hon. Arthur A. Garcia
Hon. James E. Herman
Hon. Brian Hill
Hon. James F. Iwasko
Hon. Kay S. Kuns
Hon. J. William McLafferty
Hon. Frank J. Ochoa
Hon. James F. Rigali
Hon. Timothy J. Staffel
Hon. Joyce Allegro
Hon. Mary Arand
Hon. Jacqueline M. Arroyo
Hon. Kenneth Paul Barnum
Hon. Thang Nguyen Barrett
Hon. Paul R. Bernal
Hon. Susan Bernardini
Hon. Arthur Bocanegra
Hon. Franklin E. Bondonno
Hon. Griffin M. J. Bonini
Hon. Jerome E. Brock
Hon. Gilbert T. Brown
Hon. Andrea Y. Bryan
Hon. Neal Anthony Cabrinha
Hon. Thomas W. Cain
Hon. David A. Cena
Hon. Sharon A. Chatman
Hon. Vincent J. Chiarello
Hon. L. Michael Clark
Hon. Paul C. Cole
Hon. Linda R. Condron
Hon. Alden E. Danner
Hon. Edward J. Davila
Hon. Raymond J. Davilla, Jr.
Hon. Ron M. Del Pozzo
Hon. My-Le Jacqueline Duong
Hon. Thomas C. Edwards
Hon. William J. Elfving
Hon. James C. Emerson
Hon. Alfonso Fernandez
Hon. Catherine A. Gallagher
Hon. John J. Garibaldi
Hon. Mary Ann Grilli
Hon. Teresa Guerrero-Daley
Hon. John F. Herlihy
Hon. Joseph Huber
Hon. Eugene Michael Hyman
Hon. Jamie A. Jacobs-May
Hon. Margaret Johnson
Hon. Peter H. Kirwan
Hon. James P. Kleinberg
Hon. Lucy H. Koh
Hon. Jack Komar
Hon. Kurt E. Kumli
Hon. Edward Frederick Lee
Hon. Mary Jo Levinger
Hon. Richard J. Loftus, Jr.
Hon. Patricia M. Lucas
Hon. Katherine Lucero
Hon. Stephen V. Manley
Hon. Socrates Peter Manoukian
Hon. Michele McKay McCoy
Hon. Beth A. R. McGowen
Hon. Kevin E. McKenney
Hon. William J. Monahan
Hon. Kevin J. Murphy
Hon. Jerome S. Nadler
Hon. Rene Navarro
Hon. Leslie C. Nichols
Hon. Diane Northway
Hon. Carol W. Overton
Hon. Philip H. Pennypacker
Hon. Aaron Persky
Hon. Rise Jones Pichon
Hon. Mark H. Pierce
Hon. Marcel B. Poché
Hon. Hector E. Ramon
Hon. Diane Ritchie
Hon. Shawna M. Schwarz
Hon. Kenneth L. Shapero
Hon. Douglas K. Southard
Hon. Rodney J. Stafford
Hon. Patrick E. Tondreau
Hon. Brian Walsh
Hon. Gregory H. Ward
Hon. Jean High Wetenkamp
Hon. Derek Woodhouse
Hon. Erica R. Yew
Hon. Carrie A. Zepeda
Hon. Jeff Almquist
Hon. Robert B. Atack
Hon. Michael Einum Barton
Hon. Paul P. Burdick
Hon. Denine J. Guy
Hon. Paul M. Marigonda
Hon. Heather D. Morse
Hon. John Steven Salazar
Hon. Ariadne J. Symons
Hon. Timothy R. Volkmann
Hon. Stephen H. Baker
Hon. Cara Beatty
Hon. Molly A. Bigelow
Hon. Bradley L. Boeckman
Hon. Wilson Curle
Hon. Daniel E. Flynn
Hon. William D. Gallagher
Hon. Monica Marlow
Hon. James Ruggiero
Hon. John P. Kennelly
Hon. William W. Pangman
Hon. William J. Davis
Hon. Karen L. Dixon
Hon. Laura J. Masunaga
Hon. Paul Lloyd Beeman
Hon. Robert S. Bowers
Hon. Allan P. Carter
Hon. D. Scott Daniels
Hon. Peter B. Foor
Hon. Robert C. Fracchia
Hon. Ramona Joyce Garrett
Hon. Wendy Getty
Hon. William C. Harrison
Hon. Garry T. Ichikawa
Hon. Alesia F. Jones
Hon. Scott L. Kays
Hon. Harry S. Kinnicutt
Hon. Michael Mattice
Hon. Earl Bradley Nelson
Hon. David Edwin Power
Hon. Donna L. Stashyn
Hon. Cynda Riggins Unger
Hon. Lawrence G. Antolini
Hon. Raima H. Ballinger
Hon. James G. Bertoli
Hon. Robert S. Boyd
Hon. René Auguste Chouteau
Hon. Elliot Daum
Hon. Kenneth J. Gnoss
Hon. Allan D. Hardcastle
Hon. Virginia G. Marcoida
Hon. Gary A. Medvigy
Hon. Gary Nadler
Hon. Knoel L. Owen
*Hon. Arnold D. Rosenfield
Hon. Elaine M. Rushing
Hon. Dana B. Simonds
*Hon. Mark Tansil
Hon. Arthur A. Wick
Hon. Cerena Wong
Hon. Nancy Ashley
Hon. Roger M. Beauchesne
Hon. Loretta Murphy Begen
Hon. Nan Cohan Jacobs
Hon. Ricardo Cordova
Hon. Joseph R. Distaso
Hon. John D. Freeland
Hon. Jack M. Jacobson
Hon. Hurl William Johnson III
Hon. William A. Mayhew
Hon. Linda A. McFadden
Hon. Dawna Reeves
Hon. Timothy W. Salter
Hon. Donald E. Shaver
Hon. Susan D. Siefkin
Hon. Marie Sovey Silveira
Hon. Scott T. Steffen
Hon. David G. Vander Wall
Hon. John G. Whiteside
Hon. Thomas D. Zeff
Hon. Brian R. Aronson
Hon. Christopher R. Chandler
Hon. Susan E. Green
Hon. H. Ted Hansen
Hon. Perry Parker
Hon. John J. Garaventa
Hon. Edward J. King III
Hon. Dennis E. Murray
Hon. Richard Scheuler
Hon. Anthony C. Edwards
Hon. James P. Woodward
Hon. Juliet L. Boccone
Hon. Stephen Drew
Hon. Darryl B. Ferguson
Hon. Walter L. Gorelick
Hon. Lloyd L. Hicks
Hon. James W. Hollman
Hon. Gary M. Johnson
Hon. Joseph A. Kalashian
Hon. Elisabeth B. Krant
Hon. Kathryn T. Montejano
Hon. Gary L. Paden
Hon. Melinda Myrle Reed
Hon. Glade F. Roper
Hon. Valeriano Saucedo
Hon. Gerald F. Sevier
Hon. Jennifer Conn Shirk
Hon. Paul Anthony Vortmann
Hon. James A. Boscoe
Hon. Douglas C. Boyack
Hon. Eric L. DuTemple
Hon. Eleanor Provost
Hon. Brian John Back
Hon. Jeffrey G. Bennett
Hon. Edward F. Brodie
Hon. Frederick H. Bysshe, Jr.
Hon. James P. Cloninger
Hon. Tari L. Cody
Hon. Donald D. Coleman
Hon. Ellen Gay Conroy
Hon. Manuel J. Covarrubias
Hon. Douglas W. Daily
Hon. Kevin G. DeNoce
Hon. John E. Dobroth
Hon. Kent M. Kellegrew
Hon. Barbara A. Lane
Hon. William Q. Liebmann
Hon. David W. Long
Hon. Kevin J. McGee
Hon. Patricia M. Murphy
Hon. Vincent J. O'Neill, Jr.
Hon. Glen M. Reiser
Hon. Rebecca S. Riley
Hon. John R. Smiley
Hon. Harry J. Walsh
Hon. Colleen Toy White
Hon. David R. Worley
Hon. Bruce A. Young
Hon. Steven M. Basha
Hon. Timothy L. Fall
Hon. Janet Gaard
Hon. W. Arvid Johnson
Hon. Samuel T. McAdam
Hon. Stephen L. Mock
Hon. Paul K. Richardson
Hon. David Rosenberg
Hon. Thomas E. Warriner
Hon. Kathleen M. White
Hon. Dennis J. Buckley
Hon. James L. Curry
Hon. Debra L. Givens
Hon. Kathleen R. O'Connor
Hon. Julia L. Scrog
Your Honors, This is what Caltrans told the Regional Water Quality Control Board after the Judge Tangeman August 5, 2008 decision regarding the Videos presented to Judge Tangeman.
This Statement will have an impact on all of our State Highways. "Due to past litigation, the Department is no longer responsible or allowed to maintain the channel located off of the Caltrans right of way"
-----Original Message-----
From: Pete Riegelhuth [mailto:pete_riegelhuth@dot.ca.gov]
Sent: Monday, January 12, 2009 11:06 AM
To: Matt Thompson
Cc: Harvey Packard; john_papathakis@dot.ca.gov; Marissa Nishikawa; Roger Briggs; Sorrel Marks; Tamara Presser; Steve Price
Subject: Re: Caltrans Maintenance Activity on Highway 1, Oceano
Matt,
Caltrans District 5 office would like to take this opportunity to express
its unwavering dedication to maintaining the highest levels of compliance
with environmental and water quality protective laws and policies of the
U.S., the State of California, and to the National Pollutant Discharge
Elimination System (NPDES) permit issued to the Department in 1999 (Order
NO. 99-06-DWQ) (CAS000003).
The Maintenance Engineer and Area Superintendent for this area were
interviewed regarding the complaint against the Caltrans Maintenance
activity on Highway 1 in Oceano. Even though this site has a history of
poor drainage that is beyond the control of Caltrans, it was determined
that Department roadway maintenance operations at this location are in
compliance with requirements set forth in Department Stormwater Quality
Guidance Manuals. The trucks seen with their plow blades lowered are
moving the flooded water and fallen branches off of the road way.
Department personnel maintain the entrance to the drainage channel by
shoveling sediment out of the channel and onto the banks. When the rain
event is over, Department staff return to remove the shoveled material.
The Maintenance Area Superintendent has agreed to immediately bag the
shoveled material and remove it from the area when maintaining the drainage
flow.
Due to past litigation, the Department is no longer responsible or allowed
to maintain the channel located off of the Caltrans right of way. If you
would like further information about the drainage situation and the
maintenance effort at this location, which has a history beyond what can
be detailed in an e-mail, please let me know so that I can arrange a
meeting with Department staff familiar with the drainage challenges and
restrictions at this site.
Respectfully,
Pete Riegelhuth
D-5 NPDES Coordinator
Office 805-549-3375
Cell 805-305-7726
Fax 805-542-4746
http://sv06web/pjd/stormwater/
"Matt Thompson"
<Mthompson@waterb
oards.ca.gov> To
<john_papathakis@dot.ca.gov>,
01/07/2009 05:06 <pete_riegelhuth@dot.ca.gov>
PM cc
"Marissa Nishikawa"
<marissa_nishikawa@dot.ca.gov>,
"Harvey Packard"
<Hpackard@waterboards.ca.gov>,
"Roger Briggs"
<Rbriggs@waterboards.ca.gov>,
"Sorrel Marks"
<Smarks@waterboards.ca.gov>,
"Tamara Presser"
<TPresser@waterboards.ca.gov>
Subject
Caltrans Maintenance Activity on
Highway 1, Oceano
John, Pete,
As we spoke about earlier today John, here is the blog that Oceano
businessman Bill Bookout has shared with Water Board staff and other
agencies:
http://www.oceanonurseryflooding.blogspot.com
This blog includes photos and videos of Caltrans maintenance workers
plowing and shoveling flood-related debris from Highway 1 into a roadside
ditch. Mr. Bookout says the Caltrans maintenance supervisor is David Fry
(sp?). Mr. Bookout asserts that this activity is causing a nearby culvert
beneath the railroad tracks to become clogged with debris, which
exacerbates flooding of his property.
Caltrans' NPDES stormwater permit prohibits the discharge of wastes or
wastewater from road sweeping vehicles or from other maintenance or
construction activities to any surface waters or to any storm drain leading
to surface water bodies. This maintenance activity appears to violate this
prohibition. Please direct your maintenance staff to immediately
discontinue this activity. Any flood-related debris should be scooped up
and properly disposed of in an appropriate location. If we receive any
further complaints regarding this activity, we may find Caltrans in
violation of its NPDES requirements and pursue formal enforcement action.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
--Matt Thompson
Regional Water Quality Control Board
Central Coast Region
895 Aerovista Place, Suite 101
San Luis Obispo, California 93401
V (805) 549-3159
F (805) 788-3572
